Get Our Blog
  • Eric Hahn

Wishing Upon A Star Manager Doesn't Work

Did you see that!? Another amazingly bright mutual fund manager burned out. After a streak of greatness, his fund’s performance went pitch black. Missed it? Just wait — they’ll be plenty more. The mutual fund universe is full of shooting stars. In fact, picking a manager based on his or her superior past return more often results in sub-par returns than a repeat performance.

Persistence studies analyze the returns of mutual funds over two independent periods to measure the link between past return to future return. Standard and Poor’s has been documenting the results in their S&P Persistence Scorecardfor several years. The results typically show little if any correlation between past performance and future returns. The June 2013 version is expected next week.

Morningstar recently published a persistence study titled The Percentile Trap. It analyzed the following categories of U.S. open-ended mutual funds during 11 five-year periods beginning in April of 1998 to March 2013: Large Value, Large Growth, Mid-Blend, Small Value and Small Growth.

Jeffrey Ptak, president and CIO of Morningstar Investment Services, reported that only 10% to 20% of top-quartile funds in each category remained in the top quartile over the subsequent five-year period. In contrast, Ptak found that on average, 20% to 30% of top quartile funds from the previous five years fell to the bottom quartile in performance in the next five years.

Maintaining consistently high performance is so difficult for fund managers that less than half (10% to 20%) of the top quartile funds were even able to stay in the top half over the next five years. Approximately 30% to 40% of funds in each category finished in the top half after accounting for funds that go out of business, merged with another fund or changed style categories.

The Morningstar article provided an interesting analysis of where winning funds come from. They found a majority of winning funds in each category were new or new to that category. Of the funds that were in existence and in the same category for long time, more bottom performing funds become top quartile funds in the second five-year period as the winning funds of the past fell out of favor.

I’ve been interested in persistence studies since Mark Carhart published the first detailed analysis on the subject in 1997, On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance. The numbers shift around a bit from one period to another, but in total, the link between past performance and future return is almost nonexistent. The best way to treat past performance is as random. There’s an equal chance for a winning fund to be in the top, bottom, or go out business over the next period.

Past performance is a poor indication of future results as every learned investor knows. Yet this remains the primary factor used by individuals and advisers to select fund managers. 71% of current owners rank past performance as “very influential” or “somewhat influential” when selecting mutual funds, according to survey conducted by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA) and funded by the NASD Investor Education Foundation.

The fact that most people believe that past performance can predict future returns is a triumph of marketing over substance. We see mutual fund companies heavily promote past performance in newspapers and magazines, on television and radio, and all over the Internet. The micro-print under this performance always includes the required SEC disclosure about using past performance, but that’s not what people see. They see the BIG and BOLD print promoting a fund’s past return, its high rating based on past performance, and talk about how expert the managers are. In five years, these funds will fade into obscurity and there will be a different set of best past performers.

Past performance does not provide useful information about future performance. Wishing upon a star is a fine fantasy for children, but it doesn’t work for adults who are trying to earn a fair return from their mutual funds.

Portfolio &
Money Management


Contact Us

4 Landmark Square - Suite 315
Stamford, CT 06901





ADV Part 2 | ADV Part 3 (CRS) Privacy Policy | Cyber Security Policy | Business Continuity Plan Client Secure Upload


Check the background of this firm on FINRA’s BrokerCheck.           


NS Capital LLC is a Registered Investment Adviser. NS Capital and its representatives are in compliance with the current filing requirements imposed upon registered investment advisers by those states in which NS Capital maintains clients. NS Capital may only transact business in those states in which it is registered, or qualifies for an exemption or exclusion from registration requirements. NS Capital’s web site is limited to the dissemination of general information pertaining to its advisory services, and through the NS Blog access to additional investment-related information, publications, and links.  Accordingly,  NS Capital’s web site on the Internet should not be construed by any consumer and/or prospective client as NS Capital’s solicitation to effect, or attempt to effect transactions in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation, over the Internet.  Any subsequent, direct communication by NS Capital with a prospective client shall be conducted by a representative that is either registered or qualifies for an exemption or exclusion from registration in the state where the prospective client resides. For information pertaining to the registration status of NS Capital, please contact the SEC or the state securities regulators for those states in which NS Capital maintains a notice filing.  A copy of NS Capital current written disclosure statement discussing NS Capital’s business operations, services, and fees is available from NS Capital upon written request. NS Capital does not make any representations or warranties as to the accuracy, timeliness, suitability, completeness, or relevance of any information prepared by any unaffiliated third party, whether linked to NS Capital’s web site or incorporated herein, and takes no responsibility such content.  All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users should be guided accordingly.


Please remember that different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that the future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy (including those undertaken or recommended by NS Capital), will be profitable or equal any historical performance level(s).


Certain portions of NS Capital’s web site (i.e. newsletters, articles, commentaries, etc.) may contain a discussion of, and/or provide access to, NS Capital (and those of other investment professionals) positions and/or recommendations as of a specific prior date.  Due to various factors, including changing market conditions, such discussion may no longer be reflective of current position(s) and/or recommendation(s).  Moreover, no client or prospective client should assume that any such discussion serves as the receipt of, or a substitute for, personalized advice from NS Capital, or from any other investment professional. NS Capital is neither an attorney nor an accountant, and no portion of the web site content should be interpreted as legal, accounting or tax advice. 


Rankings and/or recognition by unaffiliated rating services and/or publications should not be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience a certain level of results if NS Capital is engaged, or continues to be engaged, to provide investment advisory services, nor should it be construed as a current or past endorsement of NS Capital by any of its clients.  Rankings published by magazines, and others, generally base their selections exclusively on information prepared and/or submitted by the recognized adviser. Each client and prospective client agrees, as a condition precedent to his/her/its access to NS Capital web site, to release and hold harmless , NS Capital’s officers, directors, owners, employees and agents from any and all adverse consequences resulting from any of his/her/its actions and/or omissions which are independent of his/her/its receipt of personalized individual advice from NS Capital.

© 2020-2025 NS Capital LLC. All Rights Reserved.